Get the Sunday Recap
Scoreboard moves — the pundits' and ours — every Sunday. Free.
EVERY PICK ON RECORD · SCORED LIKE EVERYTHING ELSE HERE
Pundit Scores
TV guests and newsletter writers make public stock picks every week — and almost nobody checks how they turn out. We log the pick, the date, and the source, then mark it against the index with the same methodology as everything on this site. Wins, losses, receipts.
| Pundit | Affiliation | Picks | Beating index | Avg vs index |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rebecca Teltscher | Portfolio Manager, Newhaven Asset Management · BNN Bloomberg Market Call guest | 6 | 3/6 | +3.9 |
| Jim Cramer | Host, CNBC's Mad Money · former hedge fund manager | 17 | 9/17 | +0.4 |
| Chris Blumas | Portfolio Manager, Raymond James Investment Counsel · BNN Bloomberg Market Call guest | 3 | 0/3 | −1.4 · small sample |
| Barry Schwartz | President & CIO, Baskin Wealth Management · frequent BNN Bloomberg Market Call guest | 12 | 3/12 | −5.6 |
| Brian Madden | Chief Investment Officer, First Avenue Investment Counsel · BNN Bloomberg Market Call guest | 3 | 0/3 | −10.7 · small sample |
How pundits get scored
Each pick is logged with its air or publication date and a source link, entered at that day’s closing price, and marked daily against its market’s index — the S&P/TSX Composite for Canadian picks, the S&P 500 for US ones. Nothing is deleted; small samples are labeled. Picks are public statements, reported factually. Spot an error? Tell us — corrections get logged too.